Skip to content
HIPAA ComplianceConsulting

HIPAA Guide

HIPAA Compliance Audit vs. Assessment

A clear comparison of OCR audits and investigations, internal audits, third-party assessments and gap analyses — and why a private assessment is never a government audit.

5 min read Reviewed

"We need a HIPAA audit" can mean several very different things. Sometimes it means OCR has opened an investigation. Sometimes it means a hospital customer wants evidence before signing a contract. Sometimes it means leadership wants an honest picture of where the program stands. Each calls for a different kind of review, a different reviewer, and a different deliverable.

This guide separates the four activities most often confused and explains how they relate.

Key points

  • Only HHS/OCR conducts government HIPAA audits, compliance reviews and investigations.
  • Internal audits, third-party assessments and gap analyses are voluntary tools that help you prepare and improve.
  • No private assessment certifies compliance or binds OCR.
  • Most OCR enforcement starts with a complaint or breach report, not a random audit.

OCR audits, compliance reviews and investigations

HITECH requires HHS to conduct periodic audits of covered entities and business associates. OCR has run audit programs in phases over the years, using desk audits that request specific documentation — commonly risk analysis, risk management, breach notification and patient access materials. OCR audits have historically been described as improvement-oriented, but findings can lead to a separate compliance review.

Far more common are complaint investigations and compliance reviews triggered by breach reports. Under the Enforcement Rule (45 CFR Part 160, Subpart C), OCR can request documents, interview staff and review practices. Outcomes range from closure with technical assistance, to a resolution agreement with a corrective action plan, to civil money penalties.

Internal audits

An internal audit is performed by your own staff — typically compliance, internal audit or IT security — to test whether policies are being followed. Examples include monthly reviews of EHR access logs for inappropriate access, quarterly checks that terminated users were deprovisioned, or annual sampling of patient access requests for timeliness.

Internal audits support several Security Rule requirements directly, including information system activity review (§164.308(a)(1)(ii)(D)), audit controls (§164.312(b)) and periodic evaluation (§164.308(a)(8)). Their strength is frequency and institutional knowledge; their weakness is that people tend to miss problems in processes they designed.

Third-party assessments

An independent assessment is performed by an outside firm against HIPAA requirements and, often, a recognized framework such as NIST SP 800-66 Rev. 2 or NIST CSF. It may include a formal risk analysis, technical testing, policy review and interviews. The output is a report of findings and recommendations.

Third-party assessments are useful when you need an objective view, lack internal capacity, are preparing for a customer's due diligence, or want to evidence your program before an anticipated OCR inquiry. See HIPAA audit readiness for how preparation engagements typically work.

Gap analyses

A HIPAA gap analysis maps your current state against each applicable requirement and identifies what is missing or incomplete. It is usually faster and narrower than a full assessment and is a common starting point for organizations building or rebuilding a program. A gap analysis is not a risk analysis: it tells you whether a control exists, not how exposed your ePHI is.

Comparison table

ActivityWho performs itTriggerTypical outputBinding effect
OCR auditHHS Office for Civil Rights or its contractorSelection under HITECH audit programAudit findings reportGovernment review; may lead to compliance review
OCR investigation / compliance reviewHHS Office for Civil RightsComplaint, breach report, referralClosure, technical assistance, resolution agreement or penaltyEnforcement action
Internal auditYour own workforcePolicy schedule, risk findingsAudit logs, exception reports, remediation ticketsInternal only
Third-party assessmentIndependent outside firmLeadership, customer or board request; readinessAssessment report, risk register, remediation roadmapAdvisory; not a certification
Gap analysisInternal team or outside firmProgram build or refreshRequirement-by-requirement gap listAdvisory

What reviewers typically ask to see

Whether the reviewer is OCR, a customer's security team or an independent assessor, the evidence requested tends to overlap. Having it organized before anyone asks is the core of readiness, and it lets you respond to an OCR data request within the deadline it sets rather than scrambling to reconstruct history.

  • The current risk analysis and prior versions, with dates showing it has been kept up to date.
  • The risk management plan or register, showing remediation status and decisions to accept risk.
  • Policies and procedures with version history, and evidence they were in effect at the relevant time.
  • Workforce training records and sanctions applied.
  • The business associate agreement inventory and signed agreements.
  • Access review records, audit log review evidence and incident logs.
  • Breach risk assessments and notification records, including the annual log of small breaches.
  • For covered entities, the notice of privacy practices and records of patient access request handling.

Language to be careful with

Because "audit" carries an air of officialdom, some vendors use it loosely. A private firm can perform an audit-style review of your HIPAA program, but it is not a government audit, and its report does not certify compliance or bind OCR. Be cautious of anyone offering an "OCR-style audit" that comes with a pass/fail certificate. A good assessor will tell you plainly what they tested, what they did not, and what risk remains.

Which one do you need?

For a working list of documents auditors typically request, see the HIPAA compliance audit checklist.

  • Received an OCR data request or complaint notice — engage legal counsel immediately and consider outside help assembling evidence; do not rely on a generic assessment.
  • Building a program for the first time — start with a gap analysis, then a full risk analysis.
  • A customer or investor wants assurance — a third-party assessment with clear scope and methodology, or a framework attestation such as SOC 2 if the market expects it.
  • Program is mature — keep running internal audits and commission a periodic independent assessment.
  • Recent breach or major system change — update the risk analysis and test the affected controls.

Frequently asked questions

Can a private company conduct an official HIPAA audit?

No. Only HHS/OCR conducts government HIPAA audits and investigations. Private firms perform assessments or audit-style reviews that help you prepare, but these have no official standing.

Does HIPAA require an annual audit?

HIPAA does not require an annual external audit. It does require periodic evaluation (§164.308(a)(8)), information system activity review and an up-to-date risk analysis. Many organizations meet these through a mix of internal audits and periodic outside assessment.

How do OCR investigations usually start?

Most begin with a complaint from a patient or employee, or with a breach report submitted to HHS. OCR may also open compliance reviews based on media reports or referrals.

Will a third-party assessment protect us from penalties?

No assessment can guarantee a particular outcome. However, evidence of an accurate risk analysis, active risk management and recognized security practices is directly relevant to how OCR evaluates an organization.

Authoritative sources

This page is general information, not legal advice. Regulations and guidance change; confirm current requirements with the official sources above and, where needed, qualified legal counsel.

Talk through your HIPAA obligations with a consultant

Tell us about your organization, how you handle patient information, and what’s prompting the review. We’ll suggest a practical scope — and tell you if you don’t need us.